Assessment « SF State Web Template Program

program index

Summary of Usability Issues « Usability 5

Inconsistent global and sub navigation

  • Placement inconsistent relative to page and each other
  • Inconsistent content and links
  • Missing navigation
  • Logo not linked to home (not following established navigation conventions)
  • Dead ends trigger back button escape mode
  • Inconsistent footer navigation—legal, copyright, privacy, accessibility

Missing "just-in-time" navigation

  • Lacking navigation elements that provide sitewide help to users at any time
  • Lacking navigation support for frequent and common global (sitewide) actions such as search, site map, login, contact

Poor information organization and hierarchy

  • 2-D, flat organization (not enough drill-down)
  • Too much drill-down (no breadcrumbs to extricate)
  • Lack of organization impedes semantic HTML markup

Poor visual hierarchy and user feedback

  • Unclear about first action to take
  • Unclear about what information is important
  • Where am I? Which department, which site section... which academic institution?

Too many words and poor choice of words

  • Paths to information obscured by overwriting
  • Needless didactic text accompanying basic precepts
  • "Click here" as a call to action is vague, uncompelling, and a problem for disabled users browsing with screenreaders.
  • Different words for similar processes generate confusion

In a Nutshell

I often have to go to Google to find stuff on the SFSU Web site.Survey respondent

(For full survey results see Appendix.)